The biggest red flags when choosing an insurance company are weak financial strength ratings, a high volume of consumer complaints, an insurer or agent not licensed in your state, high-pressure sales tactics, prices far below every competitor, and vague answers about coverage or exclusions. Check AM Best ratings, the NAIC complaint data and your state insurance department before you buy.
Buying insurance is buying a promise. You pay now, and the company agrees to pay later, possibly years later, when you’re stressed and need help fast. That’s why the company behind the policy matters as much as the price.
Most insurers are legitimate and regulated. But some are financially shaky, some have poor claims service, and a few aren’t real insurers at all. Here are the warning signs to watch for and how to check them yourself.
Red Flags When Choosing an Insurance Company
These are the red flags we’d tell a friend to watch for when choosing an insurance company, grouped by what they reveal.
1. Weak or missing financial strength ratings
An insurer has to be able to pay claims, including after a major disaster when thousands of policyholders file at once. Independent rating agencies grade this. AM Best is the most widely used for insurers, and agencies like S&P, Moody’s and Fitch also rate many companies.
A low rating, a recent downgrade, a negative outlook or no rating at all doesn’t automatically mean trouble, especially for small regional insurers, but it deserves a closer look and a question to your agent.
2. A high complaint record
The NAIC’s Consumer Insurance Search tool shows complaint data for insurers, including a complaint index that compares a company’s complaints to its size. An index above the national baseline means more complaints than expected for a company that size. Look at the reasons too: repeated complaints about claim delays or denials tell you more than a few billing issues.
3. Not licensed in your state
Insurers and agents must be licensed by your state insurance department to sell most types of coverage. If you can’t find the company or agent in your state’s lookup tool, stop. Fake insurers and unlicensed sellers are a real problem, particularly with health coverage and auto policies.
One nuance: some legitimate specialty coverage is placed with surplus lines insurers that aren’t admitted in your state. That’s legal when done through a properly licensed surplus lines broker, but these policies usually aren’t backed by your state’s guaranty fund, so ask about it.
Sales and Pricing Warning Signs
4. A price far below everyone else
Prices vary between insurers, and shopping around saves money. But if one quote is dramatically lower than every other, find out why. It may have lower limits, a higher deductible, missing coverages or major exclusions. In the worst cases, it’s a scam.
5. High-pressure tactics
Be cautious of anyone who:
- Insists you must sign today or lose the deal
- Won’t send policy documents before you pay
- Discourages you from comparing other quotes
- Calls you unsolicited and pushes for a decision on the spot
6. Unusual payment requests
Legitimate insurers don’t ask you to pay premiums with gift cards, cryptocurrency or wire transfers to a personal account. Pay the insurer directly or through an established, licensed agency.
7. Health plans that sound too good to be true
Some products marketed as health insurance aren’t comprehensive coverage. Health care sharing ministries, discount medical cards, fixed indemnity plans and short-term plans can be legitimate products, but they generally don’t follow ACA rules. They may exclude pre-existing conditions, cap benefits or skip essential health benefits. If a seller can’t clearly say whether a plan is ACA-compliant, that’s a red flag.
Policy and Service Red Flags
8. Vague answers about coverage
A good agent or insurer will explain what’s covered, what’s excluded and how the deductible works. If you hear only that you’re fully covered without specifics, ask for the policy wording or a sample policy in writing.
9. Poor claims reputation
Customer satisfaction studies from groups like J.D. Power survey policyholders about claims and service. Combine these with complaint data and reviews from people who actually filed claims, not just people who bought a policy.
10. Hard-to-reach customer service
Before you buy, try calling the claims line or testing the app. If you can’t reach anyone now, imagine trying after a storm.
Your Insurance Company Checklist
- Confirm the insurer and agent are licensed on your state insurance department’s website.
- Look up the AM Best financial strength rating.
- Check complaint data on the NAIC Consumer Insurance Search.
- Review J.D. Power or similar satisfaction studies for the coverage type.
- Get at least three quotes with matching coverage limits and deductibles.
- Read exclusions and ask questions in writing.
- Pay only through official, traceable channels.
| What to check | Where to check it |
|---|---|
| License status | Your state insurance department |
| Financial strength | AM Best and other rating agencies |
| Complaints | NAIC Consumer Insurance Search |
| Customer satisfaction | J.D. Power studies |
| Health plan status | HealthCare.gov or your state exchange |
What to Do If Something Seems Off
If you suspect fraud or an unlicensed seller, don’t pay. Contact your state insurance department, which handles consumer complaints and investigates fraud. If you already bought a policy and something feels wrong, request your full policy documents and confirm the policy directly with the insurer, using contact information you find yourself, not what the seller gave you.
Green Flags Worth Looking For
It helps to know what good looks like, too. A trustworthy insurer or agent will usually:
- Send you a full quote and policy documents before asking for payment
- Explain exclusions and deductibles without being asked twice
- Give you time to compare and think it over
- Offer clear contact options for claims, including after hours
- Show up easily in your state’s license lookup and rating agency databases
Say two companies quote you similar prices for the same coverage. If one answers your questions clearly and the other dodges them, that difference is a strong signal about how each will treat you later, when you have a claim.
Bottom Line
The red flags when choosing an insurance company usually show up before you buy: weak ratings, heavy complaints, missing licenses, pressure tactics and prices or promises that don’t add up. A few minutes with your state insurance department’s lookup, AM Best and the NAIC tools can save you from a painful surprise at claim time. When in doubt, ask a licensed agent to explain the differences in writing.
Frequently asked questions
What is a good AM Best rating for an insurance company?
AM Best's top categories are A++ and A+ (Superior) and A and A- (Excellent). Many consumers look for companies rated A- or better, but also consider complaints and service.
How can I check insurance company complaints?
Use the NAIC's Consumer Insurance Search to see complaint counts and a complaint index, and check your state insurance department, which may publish its own complaint data.
Are cheap insurance companies always a bad choice?
No. Lower prices can come from efficient operations or a good fit with your risk profile. Just confirm the coverage, limits and deductible match your other quotes and that the company is licensed and financially sound.
Read also
You may also search for: insurance terms explained auto insurance guide small business insurance
This article is for general information only and is not insurance, legal, tax or medical advice. Rules, coverage and prices vary by state, plan and insurer. Check your policy documents and speak with a licensed agent, your HR department or HealthCare.gov before making decisions.
